Your Barry’s Bay Insurance Broker


Request A Free Quote

It’s simple and won’t take long

COVID-19: Update

Our office is closed to the public. During this time you can still call or email your broker or account manager if you need to make changes to your insurance. A list of all of our staff and their emails are below:

Get a Free Barry’s Bay Insurance Quote Today!

Our Barry’s Bay office was one of the offices we acquired in the Ottawa Valley area. Our Barry’s Bay office has been servicing clients and their insurance needs for well over 80 years. For a small town our Barry’s Bay Insurance Brokers are able to provide a large amount of insurance solutions for Barry’s Bay. McDougall Insurance provides insurance quotes for car insurance, home insurance, recreational insurance, farm insurance, commercial insurance and life insurance. Looking to insure something that doesn’t land on that list? Try us! McDougall Insurance has access to insurance markets for hard to place items.

Barry’s Bay Car Insurance

Luckily for you, McDougall Insurance makes finding Barry’s Bay car insurance easy! Our brokers are here to help whether you are the best driver Barry’s Bay has to offer, an experienced driver who has earned a good rate, a young driver looking to get on the road on their own, or anything in between. Our Barry’s Bay insurance brokers have to access to more insurance markets than any other brokerage in Eastern Ontario! That means finding affordable car insurance for you, no matter your situation is easy. Give us a try and start seeking the rewards.

Barry’s Bay Home Insurance

Finding reliable home insurance in Barry’s Bay is not just important, it is essential. After-all your home is your biggest investment! Our Barry’s Bay insurance brokers are from the area and understand what it takes to properly insure the homes in the area because we live there and are a part of the community. We access the risks that your home could potentially face such as overland water damage, wind or hail, sewer back up and design a home insurance policy that will cover you and your home. Not to mention accidents do happen and lawsuits are more expensive now than ever before. Our Barry’s Bay home insurance brokers are here to help you in claim situations and comfort you in the event of a lawsuit.

Barry’s Bay Business Insurance

Barry’s Bay isn’t the first area that pops to mind when you’re thinking big business hubs. Nevertheless there are a ton of unique businesses throughout Barry’s Bay and the surrounding area that require and deserve an insurance plan that protects their business. Need help knowing what to insure or how to insure it? Never fear McDougall Insurance insures just about any business under the sun from; golf course insurance, hotel insurance, small business insurance, farm insurance, lumber insurance, you name it we have a business insurance market for you. To top it off our Barry’s Bay Commercial Insurance Experts guide you through a detailed commercial insurance quote to address you and your company’s individual needs. When we are satisfied with the process we set up the plan and coverage to ensure your business is protected.

What Our Customers Are Saying

Rebecca John
McDougall Insurance has been the insurance brokerage I’ve dealt with since I started buying insurance policies in 2007. I have been extremely happy with the service provided by McDougall and their staff.
Lisa Murray
I have been wtih McDougall for many years now. Gary works with you and for you to give you the best rates possible.
Stacey Noppen
Highly recommend for any insurance purposes! I have used McDougall for over 4 years now and have never had an issue. Wonderful service for my home, auto and tenants insurance. Always great communication between myself and the brokers with reassurance everything is covered.
Leah Kinghorn
Our insurance agent, Gary Plebon, goes above and beyond in caring for his clients. If you are unable to come to the office, he will take the time to come to you. He is very knowledgeable with all aspects of insurance-vehicle, home and vacation property. I have recommended Gary and McDougal Insurance to anyone looking for insurance coverage.
Cathy Pitts
We have been with McDougall for over 15 years. They are an exceptional office with great people. Quick to respond - we were hit with a tornado in 2006 - and were excellent to deal with.
Rhonda Murray
We have been a customer of McDougall Insurance for 15 years and can't say enough good things about them. We have had the pleasure of working with Gary for the entire time and honestly can't imagine having the trust I have with anyone else. Gary takes our calls, emails and texts any time we need his help. He has worked evenings and weekends in such an efficient manner that we've barely had the time to ask and it's already been taken care of.He not only keeps us up to date on anything new with our policy he also recommends ways we can save money and improve our coverage.We highly recommend McDougall Insurance to anyone who wants knowledge, friendly customer service and 100% dedication.
Stacie Pecarski
Been at mcdougall for 10 yrs now and each time my policys for the home, boat and vehicles comes up for renewal I can bet that the price I get is good. Gary is always there for any questions I have!


Recreational Insurance

Your toys need protection too! Boats, motorcycles, ATV, snowmobiles, RVs, you name it we’ve got it covered. Plus bundle your toys with your home or auto policy and truly experience what it means to be Frugal!

McDougall Family Fund 2021!

Congratulations to this years winners! Our McDougall Family Fund is back! Go to our Facebook Page for full details. What is the McDougall Family Fund Contest? This is our 8th year of our McDougall Family Fund Contest! That means we will be...

COVID-19 Update

Our offices are open to the public.

We are doing our utmost to protect our customers and our staff and following the Province wide lockdown protocols.

Business can still be conducted online, through email or over the phone. For a list of staff emails go to: Staff Profiles