Monkman Insurance is Now a Part of Team McDougall!

Request A Free Quote

It’s simple and won’t take long


Get a Free Peterborough Insurance Quote Today!

Monkman Gracie & Johnston Insurance Brokers are now a part of the McDougall Insurance family. With over 60 years experience operating in the Peterborough area, the MGJ Insurance Team combines their knowledge and relationships with McDougall Insurance size and market access to make sure you find an affordable policy with the highest level of service. Our team has the ability to cover your home and auto insurance, any business or commercial insurance needs, as well as your life insurance needs, providing all of this coverage under one roof. After all we want to make insurance as easy as possible so you can get back to doing the things you love.

Peterborough Car Insurance

Our Peterborough insurance brokers have the knowledge and expertise to help find you car insurance coverage that makes sense for your situation. Thanks to the merger of McDougall Insurance and Monkman Gracie & Johnston we now have access to more auto insurance markets than any other broker in Eastern Ontario. What does that mean for you? It means we can find the best coverage options at an affordable price. No matter what your situation is talk to one of our Peterborough insurance brokers about your car insurance and let us help you!

Peterborough Home Insurance

Your home is your biggest investment and needs to be protected properly. Our Peterborough Insurance Brokers are here to help you protect your biggest investment. With so many different coverage options available you need a broker who is from the Peterborough area to ensure you have the appropriate coverage for your home. Let one of our brokers help keep what is important to you safe! Start by getting a free home insurance quote today.

Peterborough Business Insurance

Peterborough is home to some fine commercial industries. Manufacturing has long dominated the Peterborough business landscape but new sectors are frequently arising. No matter what industry you are in McDougall Insurance knows business insurance! Our commercial experts will work with you to uncover what exposures and risks your company faces and build a comprehensive business insurance plan to meet your needs. Protecting your business is not just important it is necessary and with the help of a McDougall Commercial Insurance Broker we will make sure it is done correctly.

What Our Customers Are Saying

Candy Brinklow
Kristen Fletcher works fast and effciantly to help with our needs. We have had insurance with McDougalls for many years. She finds the best possible rates for us every year! I give her 5 stars!
Jessica Wheeler
We have had our home, auto, and business insurance with McDougall's Brighton branch for years. All of the staff in Brighton are courteous and helpful. Kristen Fletcher has been excellent with our account, always searching for our best rate and alerting us to new information and deals that we may be interested in. She is easy to deal with and responds very quickly to questions and requests. I have referred this branch to friends and family and will continue to do so! It's awesome to have this kind of service in our small town!
First Place Trailers
We brought our commercial to McDougall Insurance 8 years ago. Kristen Fletcher has been our broker since day one. The service we have received from her has been second to none. The folks at McDougall have been extremely responsive and as we have grown Kristen has kept up with the changes and growth in our business. We also brought over all of our personal policies and have received the same level of service. I give them an A+
Ron Arends
Mcdougall Insurance Brighton has been insuring our home and business for years. The service and care Kristen and staff take to ensure our needs are being met, and taking the time recognize us as people first.
Rebecca John
McDougall Insurance has been the insurance brokerage I’ve dealt with since I started buying insurance policies in 2007. I have been extremely happy with the service provided by McDougall and their staff.
Sierra Gate Homes
My grandparents, my parents, my husband and I have insured our homes, cottage, vehicles and business through McDougall Insurance & Financial in Brighton for decades. We would never consider going anywhere else for our insurance needs. Kristen Fletcher, our broker, provides exceptional service. She's absolutely one of a kind! You will not find anyone friendlier. Kristen is extremely knowledgeable, and is always very quick to reply to our e-mails and return our phone calls. She has our best interests at heart and works tirelessly to find us the best possible rates. In short, Kristen and the team in Brighton run a first-class operation. I cannot recommend them highly enough!
Darby Flindall
Kristen Fletcher in the Brighton office has been super helpful and knowledgeable with all of my business insurance needs and questions over the past years since we switched to McDougall. She works hard to keep me at the best possible rate, and she is easily reached. I appreciate the help and that it is local, as it saves me time. The other staff in Brighton are also very nice and helpful as well!

Recreational Insurance

Your toys need protection too! Boats, motorcycles, ATV, snowmobiles, RVs, you name it we've got it covered. Plus bundle your toys with your home or auto policy and truly experience what it means to be Frugal!

Is Mortgage Life Insurance Worth It?

Buying a house is one of the biggest decision of your life, and can often be a daunting or overwhelming experience. And one of the biggest decisions that comes with buying a house is picking out a good mortgage. Often you will get your mortgage from a trusted...